Tuesday, December 9, 2025

Notes on the final section of "Secret City"

As always, I'm grateful to Mike Mazza for sharing his extensive, detailed notes on James Kirchick's Secret City: The Hidden History of Gay Washington, which we'll finish discussing on Dec. 17. These notes cover the second half of the Reagan section (Chapters 38-41), as well as the George H.W. Bush and Bill Clinton presidencies. Enjoy!

Note: The citations (e.g., loc 78, 8%, etc.) below refer to the Kindle edition, not the paperback.

Secret City—Reagan notes, updated.

Chapter 38: “‘Them’ Is ‘Us’”: p 567; loc 10389; 52%.

—Bob Bauman comes out of the closet in a speech.

—CAIR, organization trying to make Republican Party more gay friendly.

—Rock Hudson and the Reagans: 569. Larry Kramer calls out Nancy.

-“the era’s decadence and hypocrisy”: 571.

—impact and stigma of AIDS.

—Rock Hudson’s AIDS diagnosis made public: 573.

—inappropriate jokes about AIDS and homosexual in the Reagan WH: 575.

—Reagan ignores AIDS crisis in his memoir: 577.

—Bill Buckley, his wife Pat, and her gay male companions: 579.

—Bill Buckley’s vile suggestion, in a 1986 column, that all people with AIDS be tattooed as a warning sign.

—John Ford stands up to an attempt to blackmail him with a threatened outing to Secretary of Agriculture John Block: 582.

Chapter 39: “‘Our Sebastian’”: p 583; loc 10693; 54%.

—young death of gay conservative activist Terry Dolan.

—controversy over reporting AIDS as Dolan’s cause of death.

—WH speechwriter Tony Dolan’s problematic eulogy for his brother; Brideshead Revisited reference.

—separate memorial to Dolan held; attended by gay conservatives: 588.

—The Washington Post’s Bradlee decides to pursue the Dolan story: 589.

—Tony Dolan tries to convince Post reporter Elizabeth Kastor to abandon her article about Terry Dolan: 590. He continues his attempts to stop the article.

Chapter 40: “Mr. Green”: p 594; loc 10898; 55%.

—introduces Carl “Spitz” Channell, founder of conservative activist group.

—Channell attends a pro-Contra presentation by Oliver North.

—Channell: a gay man who had started his career working for Terry Dolan’s NCPAC: 595.

—Channell’s anti-Communist zeal: 596.

—He starts his own Channell Corporation. Bauman visits his office.

—Channell’s efforts in the work to raise money to support the Contras in Nicaragua.

—Channell and Oliver North: 597.

—Reagan signs a letter endorsing the work of Channell’s organization: 599.

—Channell’s staff: “‘Those gay boys of Oliver North’s’”: 599.

—gay staffers on Republican campaigns: 600.

—“‘a perverse form of self-esteem’” comment on gay staff of right wing politicians (p 600); my note: cf Bill Maher’s comment to Larry King that “hating yourself can be the greatest love of all.”

—the ugly side of Channell : 601.

—Margaret Scattergood’s activities after the death of her partner Florence Thorne: 602.

—Channell and Fawn Hall: 603.

—Grifting by Channell? He pleads guiltily and fingers Oliver North. Role of “Fruit Loop” in the scandal. Irony of the elitist closeted gay cabal within the Iran-Contra scandal.

Chapter 41: “The Wonderful, the Creative, and the Brave”: p 607; loc 11,137; 56%.

—introduces Republican Congressman Stewart B. McKinney: a married father living a secret gay life in Washington.

—McKinney: 1st Congressman to die of AIDS: 607.

—the Washington Post’s approach to reporting on McKinney’s death and life: 608.

—before his death, McKinney writes a letter in support of a Connecticut state gay rights ordinance: 608.

—After final unsuccessful attempts to get Tony Dolan to speak on the record, the Washington Post publishes Kastor’s article on Terry Dolan and the gay conservative closet: 610.

—Washington Times runs Tony Dolan’s rebuttal of the Kastor article as a lengthy paid advertisement: 612.

—in his diatribe, Tony Dolan claims Terry rejected homosexuality in a deathbed conversion.

—Drama behind Reagan’s speech at an amfAR benefit dinner: 613+.

—Tony Dolan’s rage against WaPo continues: 615.

—Bob Bauman pops up again: 616.

—Openly gay Dr. Frank Lilly appointed by Reagan to new AIDS commission: 617.

—Gary Bauer in the Reagan administration.

—the 2nd March on Washington for lesbian and gay rights: 619.

—unveiling of AIDS quilt.

—1989 death of Chasen Gav er: 621.

Secret City—Bush, Clinton, conclusion—updated.

George H. W. Bush

Chapter 42: “Naming Names”: p 625; loc 11,448; 58%.

—decline of Craig Spence.

—Washington Times reporter Paul M. Rodriguez uncovers gay prostitution business operating from a DC-area funeral home chain.

—The Times’ many articles about Spence: 629.

—The Washington Times’ “institutional bias against homosexuality”: 632.

—the 1989 “White House callboy story” eventually fizzles out.

—failed homophobic smear campaign against Representative Tom Foley: 634.

—The Frank Rule on closeted gay hypocrisy.

—Spence dies of an overdose in a hotel room: 636.

—Washington as “simultaneously the gayest and most antigay city in America”: 637.

—Andrew Sullivan introduced: 638. His 1989 article making a conservative argument in favor of gay marriage.

—term “outing” coined in 1990: 638.

—Queer Nation’s outing of DoD spokesman Pete Williams: 639.

—continued paranoia among closeted gays.

Bill Clinton

Chapter 43: “A Profoundly Important Strength”: p 643; loc 11,752; 59%.

—Candidate Clinton makes history by explicitly appealing to gay voters for their support.

—in Clinton administration, Roberta Achtenberg becomes the first openly gay person to receive Senate confirmation for a cabinet department position: Assistant HUD Secretary: 645.

—1993 LGB March on Washington.

—“Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell”: 645.

—DOMA: 646.

—1990s AIDS toll.

—Leonard Matlovich’s tombstone: 648. Its cultural significance; his military service.

Conclusion: “The Gay Century”: p 651; loc 11,890; 60%.

—the Sumner Welles scandal recalled.

—Assessing the damage caused by homophobia: 652.

Photographs: p 654+.

Acknowledgements: p 655

—author’s work with Larry Kramer’s papers as part of a Yale College seminar. His interviewing of Kramer.

—author’s friendship with Frank Kameny.

—OPM’s formal apology to Kameny; First Lady Michelle Obama presided over ceremony.

—archival research.

—Rainbow History Project: 659.

—thanks to Christopher Hitchens: 660.

—his debt to those affected by anti-gay bigotry: “Even when it seemed that America had given up on them, they never gave up on America.” 660.

Photography Credits: p 662.

Sources: p 664.

Books: 670

—Balcerski, Bosom Friends (Buchanan and King): 670.

—Beachy, Gay Berlin: 671.

—John Boswell

—John Horne Burns, The Gallery: 672.

—Chauncey, Gay New York.

—D’Emilio, Lost Prophet (Bayard Rustin): 673.

—Doris Faber, Life of Lorena Hickok: 674.

—James Fisher, Dr. America (Thomas Dooley).

—Barney Frank, Frank: A Life in Politics.

—Griffin, All that Heaven Allows (Rock Hudson): 675.

—Alan Helms, Young Man from the Provinces.

—Andrew Hodges, Alan Turing.

—David Leavitt, The Man Who Knew Too Much: Alan Turing: 676.

—Ian Lumsden, Machos, Maricones, and Gays (Cuba): 677.

—William Mann, Wisecracker (bio of William Haines).

—Gordon Merrick.

—Jay Parini, Empire of Self (Gore Vidal bio): 678.

—George Plimpton, Truman Capote

—Susan Quinn, Eleanor and Hick: 679.

—Gary Schmidgall, Walt Whitman: A Gay Life.

—Craig Seymour, All I Could Bare: 680.

—Michael Sherry, Gay Artists.

—Justin Spring, Secret Historian (Samuel Steward bio).

—Tim Teeman, In Bed with Gore Vidal: 681.

—Nicholas von Hoffman, Citizen Cohn.

—Gregory Woods, Homintern: 682.

Notes: p 683

—Complete Prose Works of Walt Whitman.

—John Ibson, Men Without Maps: 688.

—Richard Plant, The Pink Triangle.

—Claud Cockburn, 697.

—author interview of Bob Bauman: 725.

—Oliver Stone’s JFK: 741.

—the Brideshead Revisited teddy bear phenomenon as experienced by Christopher Hitchens: 782.

—Larry Craig scandal: 783.

—Mark Robert Schneider, Gerry Studds (bio): 787.

—Saint Sebastian and gay culture: 791.

—“a perverse kind of self-esteem”: 794.

—The wordy Tony Dolan strikes again: 796.

No comments: